If you want my pick to listen to based on this list, I am with the fans and think Menzingers "On the Impossible Past" is the one to hear. It's a great mixture of pop punk and indie rock. The vocals are well delivered. Songs are catchy. There's a good variety of tempos happening on this album, so you don't think everything is fast or everything is slow. I love the song The Obituaries and think you should give that song a listen to get a feel for what this band can do.